A company may have strong arguments to challenge a tax claim and still compromise its defence on procedural grounds. Submitting incomplete documents, choosing the wrong route between administrative and judicial proceedings, or failing to challenge irregularities in the tax assessment can have consequences as significant as the dispute over whether the tax applies at all.
This situation takes on new contours with Complementary Law No. 236/2026, which introduced into the National Tax Code (CTN) general rules on administrative tax proceedings, applicable to the Federal Government, the States, the Federal District and the Municipalities.
The reform sets national parameters for the exercise of the right to be heard and the right to a full defence, regulates the requirements for infringement notices, the production of evidence, appeals and nullities, and provides for a period for the federative entities to adapt their legislation.
The changes represent a step forward in protecting taxpayers, but they also raise an important question for companies: will the strategies currently used to conduct their administrative proceedings remain suitable under the new rules?
Administrative tax proceedings are an important instrument for reviewing the legality of tax claims. Through them, taxpayers can challenge the grounds of an assessment before the dispute is brought before the courts.
Although the guarantees of due process, the right to be heard and the right to a full defence are already ensured by the Federal Constitution, their application has always coexisted with differences between the procedures adopted by the various taxing entities.
Complementary Law No. 236/2026 seeks to reduce these asymmetries by incorporating into the CTN a set of minimum parameters, without removing the federative entities’ power to organise their own adjudication structures.
In this context, one of the significant changes is the new Article 208-B, which sets mandatory requirements for infringement notices: in addition to identifying the taxpayer and describing the facts, the tax authority must indicate the legal provisions infringed and the applicable penalty, and demonstrate the correspondence between the situation identified and the scenario provided for in tax legislation.
This last requirement deserves particular attention. It is not enough for the tax authorities to point out that an irregularity exists. They must demonstrate why the facts established fall within the legal rule used as the basis for the claim.
The distinction may be decisive in assessments involving complex transactions, differing interpretations of the legislation or questions about whether the taxable event actually occurred.
The reform also regulates, in Article 208-H, the review of the legality of administrative acts, including grounds for nullity, such as assessments without legal basis and acts performed by authorities lacking jurisdiction.
This does not mean that any formal flaw will automatically lead to the cancellation of the claim. The legislation sets criteria for identifying nullities and their effects on other procedural acts.
For companies, this change reinforces the importance of assessing not only the merits of the claim, but also the legal regularity of the assessment and of the procedure followed by the tax authorities.
Another significant change is the new Article 208-D, which regulates deadlines, appeals and the submission of evidence in administrative tax proceedings.
Among other parameters, the provision sets deadlines of 20 days for the objection (impugnação) and the voluntary appeal, as well as for the special appeal, where applicable, and five days for motions for clarification. It also provides for procedural deadlines to be counted in business days and suspended between 20 December and 20 January, aligning administrative proceedings with the rules already in force for court proceedings, including the year-end recess, and avoiding uncertainty for taxpayers.
However, one of the most important aspects for companies lies not so much in the deadlines as in the rules governing the submission of arguments and evidence.
The provision requires taxpayers to present the factual and legal grounds for their claim at the first opportunity to make a submission in the proceedings, together with the documentary evidence available. Any later submission of new material will therefore be limited to the situations provided for by law, such as the impossibility of timely submission due to force majeure, the emergence of new facts or rights, and the need to respond to material introduced later in the proceedings.
The practical consequence is significant. In disputes involving corporate transactions, the use of tax credits, calculation criteria or the classification of taxable transactions, the defence may depend on contracts, accounting documents, tax records and information produced by different areas of the company.
Obtaining and analysing this material is not always simple, especially when it concerns transactions carried out in previous financial years.
For this reason, preparing the defence should not begin only when the objection is drafted, but with the early identification of tax risks, the organisation of documents and the definition of the relevant legal grounds.
The consistency of the initial defence may be decisive for the conduct of the entire administrative litigation.
The choice between the administrative and judicial routes also deserves particular attention.
The new Article 208-E requires taxpayers to inform the Tax Administration when the matter discussed in the administrative proceedings has been brought before the courts, so that it can be assessed whether the subject matter of the disputes is the same.
Filing a lawsuit with the same subject matter entails waiving the right to appeal administratively and withdrawing any appeal already filed. This provision reinforces the need to carefully assess the procedural strategy before starting court proceedings.
The administrative route may offer significant opportunities to have the assessment reviewed, to develop technical arguments and to apply administrative precedents. In other situations, judicial relief may be necessary to protect rights or to prevent the immediate consequences of the tax claim.
There is therefore no single answer for every dispute. The choice should take into account the grounds of the claim, the documentation available, the stage of the procedure, the applicable case law and the effects of using each route.
For companies managing multiple tax proceedings, isolated decisions to go to court may affect the overall litigation management strategy.
The reform also introduces mechanisms aimed at greater predictability in administrative rulings.
Article 208-C regulates aspects of appeals and levels of adjudication, while Article 208-F requires decisions and rulings to state clearly the factual and legal grounds on which they are based. In addition, tax administrations must make their decisions available for public consultation.
The publication of administrative guidance may help identify divergent interpretations, assess the grounds used by adjudicating bodies and define consistent strategies for similar disputes.
Another relevant point is the prohibition of hierarchical appeals to members of the Executive Branch against final administrative decisions favourable to the taxpayer, provided for in Article 208-C, paragraph 2. Protecting the stability of these decisions is an important element of legal certainty.
Complementary Law No. 236/2026 came into force on 4 September 2026, but established a specific regime for adapting the rules on administrative tax proceedings.
Article 211-B provides for a two-year period for the Federal Government, the States, the Federal District and the Municipalities to update their legislation, incorporating the minimum parameters set out in Articles 208-A to 208-J.
In the absence of such adaptation, the provision requires the CTN rules to apply until specific legislation compatible with the new parameters is enacted.
This means that the reform will not necessarily have uniform and immediate effects on all ongoing administrative proceedings. It will be necessary to examine the legislation applicable to each federative entity, the stage of implementation of the new provisions and the particular features of existing procedures.
The adaptation period, however, does not override the constitutional guarantees already ensured to taxpayers.
For companies, the transition period is an opportune moment to assess whether their defence strategies are adequate, without assuming that the new rules automatically allow earlier proceedings to be reviewed or annulled.
The changes introduced by Complementary Law No. 236/2026 are not limited to the internal organisation of tax administrations. They may also significantly affect how companies manage their contingencies and structure their defence strategies.
In this context, a review of existing tax litigation may identify assessments whose grounds deserve re-examination, proceedings with evidentiary issues not yet sufficiently explored, opportunities to apply procedural guarantees and situations in which the administrative or judicial strategy should be reconsidered.
For companies operating in different States and Municipalities, this analysis is particularly relevant given the diversity of the regimes currently in place and the changes expected during the transition period.
This is not a matter of presuming that the reform will produce favourable outcomes in every case, but of recognising that new procedural rules may change the assessment of risks, defence options and the costs of maintaining tax disputes.
Efficient litigation management therefore requires more than tracking deadlines and filing appeals. It requires understanding the features of each claim and assessing, in an integrated way, its legal, documentary and economic aspects.
Complementary Law No. 236/2026 represents a step forward by establishing national parameters for administrative tax proceedings and strengthening taxpayers’ fundamental guarantees. However, the existence of these guarantees does not, in itself, ensure that they are properly used in each dispute.
The effectiveness of the changes will depend both on the conduct of the tax administrations and on taxpayers’ ability to identify the procedural tools available and use them in a technically consistent manner.
For companies, the challenge will lie not only in knowing the new provisions, but in examining how they may affect existing proceedings, new assessments and future decisions on the conduct of their litigation.
Reviewing defence strategies, especially during the transition period, may be an important risk management measure and a way of protecting business interests.
After all, a new relationship between tax authorities and taxpayers is not built solely by expanding the guarantees provided by law. It requires these guarantees to be effectively observed by the Administration and properly exercised by those for whom they are intended.
Read more in this series:
Rua Ministro Godoi, 478, 4th Floor
São Paulo, SP 05015-000, Brazil